A number of inedible species of
Crepidotus can be superficially similar. They differ in that they are smaller (under 5 cm broad) and have a brown spore deposit. The common name "oyster mushroom" can refer to either
Pleurotus ostreatus or
Pleurotus populinus, both of which are edible. The latter differs from the former in that it is smaller (under 9 cm broad), grows on
aspens and
cottonwoods, and has a spore print that is white rather than lilac/grey.